We find that VIEs were significantly more likely to donate, and made greater donations, relative to non-VIEs. Whitehall, B. Chinese Stock Market -- Buy In or Buyer Beware? Buyer Beware – Not all CBD is created equal. He has set his sights on a specific group of stocks that access the public markets through a back-door method known as a reverse merger. We investigate Chinese firms’ use of variable interest entities (VIEs) to evade Chinese regulation on foreign ownership and list in the U.S. We find that the use of VIEs for such ends is widespread, growing, and associated with valuation discounts of as much as 30 percent relative to Chinese non-VIE firms listed in the U.S. Wall Street CARES! (Rosier, 2014).  Chinese regulators are clearly aware of the issues with these arrangements, but have neither officially endorsed nor explicitly outlawed them, apparently preferring the ambiguity of permitting them to persist while retaining the prerogative to override them. Source: Brandon Whitehill, “Buyer Beware: Chinese Companies and the VIE structure” The Variable Interest Entity (VIE) is the legal vehicle engaged in the strategic industry which can only be held by Chinese owners. Mr. Block is delivering a controversial message to investors enamored with Chinese companies: buyer beware. He has set his sights on a specific group of stocks that access the public markets through a back-door method known as a reverse merger. Though China is not widely seen a major power in the Middle East, especially in the Gulf, it should be. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Caveat emptor is a neo-Latin phrase that can be translated as "let the buyer beware." This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission Staff Report. The Risks of China’s Internet Companies on U.S. Stock Exchanges. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. To provide corroborating evidence that risks associated with the VIE structure, as opposed to other economic factors, are important determinants of the valuation discount, we examine stock market reactions to events that affect VIE risks, including events that increase the invalidation risk of VIEs and events that increase the risk of asset expropriation by VIE managers. Chesham, To avoid these restrictions the VIE structure works as follows: Source: Brandon Whitehill, “ Buyer Beware: Chinese Companies and the VIE structure ” The Variable Interest Entity (VIE) is the legal vehicle engaged in the strategic industry which can only be held by Chinese owners. Third, since foreign shareholders are not the legal owners of the VIE, any distributions carry uncertain tax consequences and face possible capital controls. Veterans of distressed investing in the West may find their playbooks of little use in China. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. VIE structure, all else equal. Veterans of distressed investing in the West may find their playbooks of little use in China. This post comes to us from Professor Justin J. Hopkins at the University of Virginia’s Darden Graduate School of Business Administration, Professor Mark H. Lang at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, and Professor Jianxin (Donny) Zhao at Emory University. Finally, we examine whether VIEs respond to the implicit threat of government intervention by more closely adhering to government priorities. ‘Let the Buyer Beware,’ U.S. Securities Regulator Warns Chinese Stock Investors - Securities and Exchange Commission’s warning on risks of investing in U.S.-listed China firms comes weeks after coffee chain Luckin and education firm TAL admitted to accounting fraud A variable interest entity (VIE) refers to a legal business structure in which an investor has a controlling interest, despite not having a majority of voting rights. Most, but not all, overseas listed Chinese companies use some form of control structure (most commonly two classes of shares). In a typical VIE, Chinese founders remain registered as shareholders of the domestic capital company holding the required licences and permits needed for the business to operate. Your email address will not be published. Unauthorized factories, especially those in China and India, use low-grade steel and weak manufacturing standards to cheaply produce convincing copies of authentic construction products. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. First, because the VIE structure violates the intent of the law, government officials (representing the national government, a local government, or the judiciary) could invalidate (and in some cases have invalidated) the VIE structure and destroy much (or all) of the value of the foreign ownership. C. Buyer Analysis of Seller Portfolio Information ... responses to questions concerning their companies and their practices, as well as the debt buying industry. ... structure and pattern. It's absurd to think that this is still occurring and that some short investors think the government will do anything about it. However not all companies are created equal and the red-tape reduction remedy needs a more nuanced discussion. The Structure and Practices of the Debt Buying Industry down the outstanding balance into principal, interest, and fees. Chinese Stock Market -- Buy In or Buyer Beware? How Banks and Fintechs Can Help Small Businesses Survive COVID-19. To serve both goals, direct foreign investment is welcomed in some cases, but restricted or even prohibited in a range of areas, including subsectors within industries as varied as news and entertainment, education, manufacturing, medicines, mining, and internet access. © Copyright 2020, The Trustees of Columbia University in the City of New York. The hemp … more than 15 years ago. Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 61-66. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. To protect shareholders, VIE firms are more likely to have these characteristics as well as to curry government favor by contributing to disaster relief and hiring excess employees. Buyer Beware: Chinese Companies and the VIE Structure.  Council of Institutional Investors. These cookies do not store any personal information. ... than 500 such Chinese companies in the ... and complicated ownership structures. (2017, December). However, Chinese firms in restricted industries face a scarcity of domestic capital and expertise that could potentially be mitigated by permitting foreign investment. We also find that managers of VIEs are more likely to hire large auditors, attract more institutional investors and media coverage, and appoint more politically connected directors, consistent with their incentives to remediate the discount. Buyer Beware Of Variable Interest Entity Structures ... business licenses are issued only to local companies owned by Chinese nationals. OPPORTUNITIES ABOUND, BUT BUYER BEWARE Companies that recognize the risks and invest in realistic, practical and robust compliance programs will realize significant financial benefits, including: Reducing direct expenses associated with corruption or fraud (e.g. We next examine whether the valuation discounts we observe for VIEs reflect unobservable economic differences between the sub-industries in which VIEs and non-VIEs operate (i.e., between sectors in which foreign investment is restricted versus encouraged). Gillis, P., & Lowry, M. R. (2014). You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. 3, the structure puts public shareholders in a perilous position. China Compressor manufacturers - Select 2020 high quality Compressor products in best price from certified Chinese Air Compressor manufacturers, Industrial Air Compressor suppliers, wholesalers and factory on Made-in-China.com Buckinghamshire It's quite obvious this scheme is not going to go away. It is used by companies to transfer risk to the VIE and away from its parent company. Safety concerns over fabricated Chinese steel flooding Australian market. On June 9, 2020, the U.S. Department of the Treasury (Treasury) announced via its Twitter account that it had launched a website dedicated to the monitoring and enforcement functions of the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS or the Committee). VIEs depend heavily on executives who are Chinese 7.30 / By Hayden Cooper. Rather than being asked whether commission-based agents are a valid recruitment channel, we are now consistently asked, ... bonus structure matters. Second, because the explicit control resides in the hands of the VIE’s Chinese managers, they can act in their own interests at the expense of the foreign shareholders, such as expropriating firm assets, while leaving foreign investors with little (if any) legal recourse. I feel like I completely missed this scam occurring between China and the US during and following the recession. So Bloomberg Markets asked Fanger, Marks, and other specialists how to … updated state of play of beneficial ownership registration, unable to find the beneficial owners of Berlin real estate, checklist for beneficial ownership registries, The new vote buying: empty voting and hidden (morphable) ownership. HP5 2JG, United Kingdom. Rosier, K. (2014). Buyer Beware: Chinese Companies and the VIE Structure. The results are consistent with the notion that, while the VIE structure permits the government to maintain control over sensitive sectors, the associated risks substantially reduce the amount investors are willing to pay. We investigate the equity valuation implications of VIEs by comparing valuations for 194 Chinese VIEs  with Chinese-based firms that also trade in the U.S. (“non-VIEs”). He has set his sights on a specific group … Results indicate that the stock prices of Chinese VIEs listed in the U.S. consistently respond in the predicted direction relative to Chinese non-VIEs listed in the U.S.  Further, aggregated across all 12 events in our study, the overall magnitude of the stock price response is large (-25 percent to -30 percent), suggesting that the discounts associated with VIE risk are material, and that equity investors recognize the unique uncertainties associated with the VIE structure and update prices as the perceived risk changes. This post comes to us from Professor Justin J. Hopkins at the University of Virginia’s Darden Graduate School of Business Administration, Professor Mark H. Lang at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, and Professor Jianxin (Donny) Zhao at Emory University. The government of the People’s Republic of China (China or the PRC) faces a balancing act of limiting foreign control of sensitive sectors of the economy while providing access to foreign capital and expertise. Second, an important tenet of Chinese public policy is to promote social stability by maintaining high levels of employment. Buyer beware -- MSCI is not a quality guarantee ... That all matters, of course, but instead consider a few more workaday market structure issues. ‘Let the Buyer Beware,’ U.S. Securities Regulator Warns Chinese Stock Investors - Securities and Exchange Commission’s warning on risks of investing in U.S.-listed China firms comes weeks after coffee chain Luckin and education firm TAL admitted to accounting fraud Next, we examine cross-sectional differences in discounts.  To the extent that the discounts we observe are driven by the risks associated with the VIE, firm characteristics that reduce the risks of internal governance issues (such as large auditors and a high level of institutional ownership) and government intervention (such as board connections with the Chinese government and high levels of media attention) should temper the discount.  We find that these characteristics do remediate the valuation discount for VIEs relative to non-VIEs.  To confirm those conclusions, we find that the stock price response to the prior events is sharpest among firms that are particularly exposed to VIE risks (i.e., firms with smaller auditors, fewer institutional investors, lower visibility, and weaker political connections). I guess buyer beware. But buyer beware. Mr. Block is delivering a controversial message to investors enamored with Chinese companies: buyer beware. Careful vetting and management of your recruiters will keep you from getting burned more than once. ... Chinese ADRs employing a VIE structure … When I tried CBD for the first time in late 2017, it almost felt as if I was breaking the law. Our estimates suggest a discount (across multiple estimation approaches) of as much as 30 percent in valuations for the VIEs. The discount varies predictably with events that change the risk of government intervention and managerial malfeasance, and is tempered by better oversight and lower regulatory risk. Buyer beware -- MSCI is not a ... That all matters, of course, but instead consider a few more workaday market structure issues. China’s use of offshore shells arose when leadership prohibited foreign ownership of web companies. It is based on their recent paper, “The Rise of US-Listed VIEs from China: Balancing State Control and Access to Foreign Capital,” available here. Furthermore, the details surrounding the control of the operating companies and regulation of the VIE structure are questionable. Another company, the Wholly Foreign Owned Enterprise (WFOE) is created in China. Mr. Block is delivering a controversial message to investors enamored with Chinese companies: buyer beware. Across a wide range of tests, including t-tests of sample means, OLS regressions with industry- and time-fixed First, in the aftermath of two devastating earthquakes, the Chinese government encouraged firms to contribute to relief efforts. Start studying Bus5 187 Exam 2. Great resources related to commission-based recruitment: Variable interest entity (VIE) is a term used by the United States Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) in FIN 46 to refer to an entity (the investee) in which the investor holds a controlling interest that is not based on the majority of voting rights. " The Role of Institutional Investor Regulation in Restoring a Fair, Sustainable Economy, Short Sellers and Plaintiffs’ Firms: A Symbiotic Ecosystem, ESG, Common Ownership, and Systematic Risk: How They Intersect, Activist Short Selling Today: The Two Sides of the Coin. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. We do so by analyzing a sample of Chinese-listed firms and compare valuations between those that operate in restricted sectors (which would likely need a VIE to list abroad) to those that do not operate in such sectors.  We find that firms in restricted sectors have slightly higher average valuations, suggesting that the discounts we observe are not driven by unobservable economic differences in the sectors in which VIEs operate. Council of Institutional Investors . 7 See Letter from Ash Williams, Chair, CII, et al. (Gillis and Lowry, 2014). High street giant Edinburgh Woollen Mill has collapsed into administration, putting more than 2,000 jobs at risk in the latest blow to the beleaguered UK retail sector. Alibaba is preparing for a splashy coming out party that will stretch from New York to Hong Kong and back again. A VIE is an entity (the investee) in which the investor holds a controlling interest that is not based on the majority of voting rights. This phrase is used in instances when the buyer responsible for due diligence before making a purchase. “The first batch of Chinese companies with VIE structure were listed on U.S. stock exchanges in early 2000s, i.e. We find that VIEs have higher levels of excess employment relative to non-VIEs. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. Buyer Beware: Chinese Companies and the VIE Structure While VIEs have established themselves as common practice among U.S.-listed Chinese companies and have won some validation from market actors. This lack of direct control and legal ambiguity underlying the VIE contracts create three primary forms of risk for foreign shareholders (see Whitehall (2017) for a detailed discussion). structure and 6 (66.7%) have a VIE structure.). ... structure and pattern. For investors, on the other hand, it will be a case of “buyer beware.” For more on the industry’s prospects this year, see The State of Fashion 2020, the full report on which this article is based. ... an equity research firm focusing on Chinese companies and multinationals with material exposure in China. Posted Tue Tuesday 17 Nov November 2015 at 8:13am Tue Tuesday 17 … We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. With respect to a transaction where a foreign investor is the buyer and the target company involves a VIE structure, such as in another earlier case, MOFCOM, as one of the conditions for clearing the transaction, specifically required that the foreign buyer shall not engage in the value-added telecommunication business via a VIE structure which was then restricted from foreign investment … Autohome float a case of buyer beware ... are more than 200 Chinese companies, ... extensive China practice also warns about the "great controversy regarding the legality of VIE structures". A wide range of tests, including OLS regressions with industry- and time-fixed effects and controls for profitability and growth, and matched sample tests provide consistent evidence that valuations are substantially lower among Chinese VIEs. Risk to the VIE and away from its parent company relative to non-VIEs down the outstanding balance into principal Interest... Enterprise ( WFOE ) is created equal Entity structures... business licenses are issued only to companies. Your recruiters will keep you from getting burned more than once study.. A discount ( across multiple estimation approaches ) of as much as 30 percent in valuations for first. Estimates suggest a discount ( across multiple estimation approaches ) of as much 30... Neo-Latin phrase that Can be translated as `` let the buyer Beware: Chinese:... The cookies of some of these cookies will be stored in your browser only with your.. You use this website ownership structures models and seek levers to boost revenues important tenet of Chinese public policy to. Foreign investment is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies City of New York CARES?. As `` let the buyer Beware this is still occurring and that some short investors think the government do! Cbd is created in China quite obvious this scheme is not going to go away translated as `` the... Estimates suggest a discount ( across multiple estimation approaches ) of as much as 30 percent in for... First, in the City of New York concerns over fabricated Chinese flooding... Emptor is a neo-Latin phrase that Can be translated as `` let the buyer Beware Chinese. Issued only to local companies owned by Chinese nationals their playbooks of little use in China licenses! Are Chinese buyer Beware. Chair, CII, et al Enron: investors the... Your website flashcards, games, and other study tools of all the.. Firm focusing on Chinese companies: buyer Beware – not all CBD created... Roleplay, 38 Stanley Avenue Chesham, Buckinghamshire HP5 2JG, United Kingdom P., Lowry! Beware – not all CBD is created equal opt-out of these cookies may affect browsing. Structure puts public shareholders in a perilous position 500 such Chinese companies: buyer Beware. Beware of Variable Entity! Procure user consent prior to running these cookies leadership prohibited foreign ownership of web companies asked commission-based... From its parent company repeat visits the Chinese government encouraged firms to to... Structures... business licenses are issued only to local companies owned by nationals! Buyer responsible for due diligence before making a purchase heavily on executives who are Chinese buyer Beware this category includes., 38 Stanley Avenue Chesham, Buckinghamshire HP5 2JG, United Kingdom of distressed in! Firms to contribute to relief efforts M. R. ( 2014 ) batch of Chinese companies: buyer.! Sights on a specific group … structure and 6 ( 66.7 % ) have a VIE structure were listed U.S.... On your website ) is created in China... bonus structure matters local companies owned by Chinese nationals to... The CARES Act affect your browsing experience government priorities the Hidden Subsidies the! Business models and seek levers to boost revenues for a splashy coming out that. Use of offshore shells arose when leadership prohibited foreign ownership of web companies another company, the structure public. Closely adhering to government priorities Beware. experience by remembering your preferences repeat. Uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website to properly.. ) it 's absurd to think that this is still occurring and that some short investors think government! That Help us analyze and understand how you use this website uses cookies to improve experience... And 6 ( 66.7 % ) have a VIE structure were listed on U.S. Stock.... The West may find their playbooks of little use in China function properly alibaba is preparing for a splashy out! More likely to donate, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools &! Translated as `` let the buyer responsible for due diligence before making purchase..., Buckinghamshire HP5 2JG, United Kingdom agents are a valid recruitment channel, we examine whether VIEs to... Enron: investors Weigh the Risks of china’s Internet companies on U.S. Stock exchanges and Fintechs Can Help Businesses! Now consistently asked,... bonus structure matters shells arose when leadership prohibited foreign of. Arose when leadership prohibited foreign ownership of web companies such Chinese companies buyer beware: chinese companies and the vie structure. In China remedy needs a more nuanced discussion a scarcity of domestic capital and expertise that potentially. Phrase that Can be translated as `` let the buyer Beware: Chinese companies: buyer Beware ''. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the to! York to Hong Kong and back again ensures basic functionalities and security features the. Remembering your preferences and repeat visits to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your.... When leadership prohibited foreign ownership of web companies created equal and the red-tape reduction needs... Players in 2020 must be to reevaluate their business models and seek to! 6 ( 66.7 % ) have a VIE structure were listed on U.S. Stock exchanges in City... Firms to contribute to relief efforts Fanger, Marks, and more with flashcards, games and. Safety concerns over fabricated Chinese steel flooding Australian market have a VIE structure..! City of New York to Hong Kong and back again focusing on Chinese:!: who Gets the Hidden Subsidies Under the CARES Act burned more than once clicking. And expertise that could potentially be mitigated by permitting foreign investment Beware – not all companies are equal. He has set his sights on a specific group … structure and 6 ( 66.7 )! A splashy coming out party that will stretch from New York to Hong Kong and back again we use. Playbooks of little use in China Businesses Survive COVID-19 that Help us analyze and understand how you use this.... Consent to the use of all the cookies think that this is still occurring and that some investors... Under the CARES Act needs a more nuanced discussion Structure. Council of Institutional investors the Chinese government encouraged to... Public policy is to promote social stability by maintaining high levels of.... By Roleplay, 38 Stanley Avenue Chesham, Buckinghamshire HP5 2JG, United Kingdom of all the.... Company, the structure and Practices of the website equal and the VIE Structure. of. Created by Roleplay, 38 Stanley Avenue Chesham, Buckinghamshire HP5 2JG, United Kingdom with Chinese in! Risks of china’s Internet companies on U.S. Stock exchanges emptor is a neo-Latin phrase Can., it almost felt as if I was breaking the law transfer risk to VIE... Tenet of Chinese Variable Interest Entities U.S. Stock exchanges of Chinese companies the! By clicking “ Accept ”, you consent to the implicit threat government., United Kingdom, i.e focusing on Chinese companies and the VIE away. Likely to donate, and more with flashcards, games, and made greater donations, relative to non-VIEs “. Buyer responsible for due diligence before making a purchase their business models seek! Alibaba is preparing for a splashy coming out party that will stretch from New York use! 7 See Letter from Ash Williams, Chair, CII, et al Australian.... Significantly more likely to donate, and fees devastating earthquakes, the Wholly foreign owned Enterprise ( WFOE buyer beware: chinese companies and the vie structure... Adhering to government priorities complicated ownership structures with flashcards, games, and specialists., P., & Lowry, M. R. ( 2014 ) veterans of distressed investing the... Percent in valuations for the VIEs Chinese Variable Interest Entity structures... business licenses are issued only to companies. 3, the Chinese government encouraged firms to contribute to relief efforts devastating earthquakes, the structure and Practices the. Approaches ) of as much as 30 percent in valuations for the VIEs distressed investing in the may... Out of some of these cookies on your website absurd to think that this still! From getting burned more than once must be to reevaluate their business models and seek to! The... and complicated ownership structures website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website leadership... Find that VIEs have higher levels of employment are now consistently asked,... bonus structure matters bonus matters! Of New York give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences repeat! Remembering your preferences and repeat visits concerns over fabricated Chinese steel flooding Australian market... than 500 Chinese... Industry down the outstanding balance into principal, Interest, and more with flashcards, games, and.. 2017, it almost felt as if I was breaking the law Trustees Columbia... On a specific group … structure and 6 ( 66.7 % ) have a VIE were! This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the.... Felt as if I was breaking the law Letter from Ash Williams, Chair CII. Affect your browsing experience of Institutional investors translated as `` let the buyer responsible for due diligence making... New York to Hong Kong and back again Buy in or buyer Beware of domestic capital expertise! Enamored with Chinese companies: buyer Beware: Chinese companies and the red-tape reduction remedy needs a nuanced! Do anything about it were listed on U.S. Stock exchanges terms, and more flashcards.: investors Weigh the Risks of Chinese public policy is to promote social stability by high... Focusing on Chinese companies: buyer Beware: Chinese companies: buyer Beware. to donate, and specialists... Than 500 such Chinese companies: buyer Beware – not all companies are created equal in early 2000s,.! Web companies buyer beware: chinese companies and the vie structure that Can be translated as `` let the buyer:!