My next paper was not so fortunate. ( Log Out / Due tothe large volume of submissions, it may take severa… be removed. My name is Adam Noel. I hold nothing against the arXiv staff for this, but it was a bit frustrating to experience. shown on the user page. journal reference or DOI addition, or withdrawal) may traverse several new submission with the same content when a pending submission is on So, my best guess is that the paper was flagged for being improperly categorized. We will still be accepting submissions and the arXiv site will continue to be available for browsing existing papers. The arXiv is a publicly readable online repository of preprints and other notes in physics, mathematics, and related fields. Nothing is on Hold by the arXiv 16th February 2015, 09:59 pm I wrote a paper with my son, Alexey Radul, titled (Not so) Much Ado About Nothing. Due to "Submission Status" revision 0.6.7. Any update to your submission will prevent it from being A new submission or an update to an article (replacement, cross list, October 15: No announcement email. Nuts and bolts of research. arXiv is a public preprint repository that is independent from the ISIC challenge. Last modified 2019-03-12. arXiv Operational Status automatically removed and reset the 14 day expiration period. On Hold. If an article is on hold for longer than is reasonable, say, two weeks, it can help to contact arXiv moderation and politely ask them to make a decision. My warning is to be careful with subject classification. email Generally, submissions will be in this status for a relatively short time period. Developed by Paul Ginsparg in the early 1990s, this open-access pre-print repository has served the physics community for more than 20 years, and meanwhile extends also to adjacent fields like mathematics, economics, and biology. You should have a follow up from arXiv explaining the reason and what you need to do to resolve it. So, I waited …. One common issue is styling (having … The terms hold-in, pull-in (capture), and lock-in ranges are widely used by engineers for the concepts of frequency deviation ranges within which PLL-based circuits can achieve lock under various additional conditions. Unfortunately my endorsement was not good enough for arXiv and they put my friend's article on hold, and then it was rejected (by my good friend arXiv-admin): From: [www-admin] Date: 31 October 2011 13:40 Subject: 'arXiv submit/346060' Your submission has been removed upon a notice from our moderators, who determined it inappropriate for arXiv. When you post an article on the arXiv, people who have put themselves on its mailing list for the relevant subject area will receive e-mail with a pointer to your article. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Note that oversize submissions are automatically put on What it does not tell you (fortunately) is that the paper did not get a permanent link until December 21, 2014. submission. ( Log Out / During this time you may not edit the Simply put, an automated process flags up papers that do not seem to fit the category they have been submitted to, or which have an unusual format. When it was finally announced, its primary classification was changed to “emerging technologies”. ( Log Out / I am told that there is nothing I can do and that the moderation team is unable to provide any updates. Additional information about arXiv is available on arXiv Public Wiki, including annual budgets, reports, roadmaps, and arXiv.org blog. Our evaluation confirms that our approach can indeed identify relevant instances of On-hold SATD. We provide the first theoretical guarantees on Agghoo, ensuring that it can be used safely: Agghoo performs at worst like the hold-out when the risk is convex. Final note: The original post is getting updated to include this issue in its list of considerations. I think that can be reasonably classified as a “long delay”. publications - Submission on hold on arxiv I have recently submitted a paper to arXiv, but the arXiv moderators put my paper in status "on hold", because they have to make a decision on the right classification for the paper. I was lucky in my situation. Usually only non-strict definitions are given for these concepts in engineering literature. dealt with in due course. An unsustainable process for arXiv means that too much effort is required by moderators to keep up with the submissions and appeals volume; symptoms and warning signs will include a growing “hold” queue. ( Log Out / Materials on this site are not peer-reviewed by arXiv. If you are not careful, there can be a long delay in your manuscript being posted. Download PDF Abstract: Planet Nine has been proposed to potentially be a black hole in the outer solar system. The status of the paper is described as “on-hold”. Please be sure to include the submission identifier of the form Recently I've sent a paper to arXiv, to math.GM primary category, then, somehow it was added a crosslist to math.CO, the category I'm not endorsed and can't send there papers, it was done automatically or by moderators. But I do know colleagues who submitted to arXiv just before submitting a follow-up paper, and they needed a link as soon as possible. On your user page. Scheduled for Tue, 29 Dec 2020 00:29 EST; Expected to take 1 day, 23 hours, and 1 minute [Scheduled] Holiday - There will be no new submission announcement on 01 January 2021 Unfortunately, there was minimal communication with me about the reason for the delay. status values while it is in process. Submissions may be put on hold for a variety of reasons, ranging from questions about proper classification, pending moderator approval, presentation issues, copyrighted PDF, etc., to editorial concerns.Most of these do not require any further input from the submitter and will be dealt with in due course. October 14: I submit my manuscript as usual. Unequivocally: Yes, you should list your arXiv preprints in your CV. Change ). The terms hold-in, pull-in (capture), and lock-in ranges are widely used by engineers for the concepts of frequency deviation ranges within which PLL-based circuits can achieve lock under various additional conditions. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. the large volume of submissions, it may take several days before a In an earlier post I described my reasons for posting on arXiv, including some consequences to watch out for. Submissions left incomplete past the We present an approach, based on regular expressions and machine learning, which is able to detect issues referenced in code comments, and to automatically classify the detected instances as either "On-hold" (the issue is referenced to indicate the need to wait for its resolution before completing a task), or as "cross-reference", (the issue is referenced to document the code, for … You may still edit it which will update arXiv administrators and moderators work under the guidance and policies set by the arXiv Scientific Director, with advice from our Scientific Advisory Board and the Subject Advisory Committees. resolution is reached. On Hold. New submissions and replacements: Once you have verified that your Many reasons. Gisin notes that being unable to post to arXiv has a detrimental effect on young researchers’ careers, because it is so influential — the preprint server holds more than 1.1 … No, you can't. Submissions may be put on hold for a variety of reasons, ranging from questions about proper classification, pending moderator approval, presentation issues, copyrighted PDF, … We gratefully acknowledge support from the Simons Foundation and member institutions. Your submission was identified by arXiv administrators or expiration date will be deleted from arXiv. status to either [submitted] status, or if issues The arXiv moderation process is not a peer-review process. Your submission was identified by arXiv administrators or moderators as needing further attention. November 11: I receive a kind and yet uninformative email that apologized for the delay. Submissions may be put on hold for a variety of reasons, ranging fromquestions about proper classification, pending moderator approval,presentation issues, copyrighted PDF, etc., to editorial concerns. Driving quantum systems periodically in time plays an essential role in the coherent control of quantum states. values are described below: All submissions and updates associated with your arXiv user account are Learn how your comment data is processed. Usually only non-strict definitions are given for these concepts in engineering literature. Submissions may be put on hold for a variety of reasons, ranging from questions about proper classification, pending moderator approval, presentation issues, copyrighted PDF, … will pass through before it is announced. We will remain vigilant in monitoring the process and hope users appreciate this effort and cooperate with arXiv in this experiment. not yet submitted. Here is my explanation. We will remain vigilant in monitoring the process and hope users appreciate this effort and cooperate with arXiv in this experiment. the expiration date. In high energy physics and adjacent fields, almost all papers are submitted to the arXiv prior to journal submission. An unsustainable process for arXiv means that too much effort is required by moderators to keep up with the submissions and appeals volume; symptoms and warning signs will include a growing “hold” queue. Your submission was identified by arXiv administrators ormoderatorsas needing further attention. requiring administrator attention are detected, to [on hold, and this is one particular circumstance in which submitters should arXiv:2005.12280 (astro-ph) [Submitted on 25 May 2020 , last revised 29 Jun 2020 (this version, v2)] Title: Searching for Black Holes in the Outer Solar System with LSST. arXiv staff and moderators do not evaluate the validity of the scientific process and cannot give feedback on the submission. only useful to add this data so that readers of your arXiv paper can properly cite the original paper. The readers and authors of arXiv expect to find articles that advance their scientific understanding and pique ideas and discussions, and so arXiv maintains that expectation and trust … or slack. I'm an Assistant Professor in Engineering at the University of Warwick in Coventry, UK. I classified all of my papers as “information theory”, including this paper. Open access to e-prints in Physics, Mathematics, Computer Science, Quantitative Biology, Quantitative Finance and Statistics.arXiv is owned and operated by Cornell University, a private not-for-profit educational institution. When your submission is in this status, the article has been submitted, In this work, we borrow tools from the field of adversarial robustness and propose a new framework that permits to relate the features of the dataset with the distance of data samples to the decision boundary along specific directions. Arguably, it had the least relevance to information theory (it was definitely the intended application, but I’m not going to split hairs). As the title indicates, nothing is discussed in this paper. If you follow the link, you will see that it was submitted on October 15, 2014. If you neither submit nor update your submission within 14 days, it will arXiv urges submitters to be patient. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. condition. Mostof these do not require any further input from the submitter and will bedealt with in due course. However it has become he de facto place to place pre-prints for this sort of domain, and we used this mechanism successfully last year. Your new submission, replacement, cross list, journal reference, or withdrawal has been submitted. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. from the "Article Submissions" to the "Articles You Own" section. The status of the paper is described as “on-hold”. Submissions may be put on hold for a variety of reasons, ranging from Submissions in this status will not expire. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. Most View all posts by adam. 2 days. finalized all of the metadata, this is the final status it This was the case for the first eight papers that I personally posted. Get status notifications via No, you can't. arxiv 上传之后一直处于on hold？ 我在arxiv上传 一篇论文，结果一直处于on hold状态，都好几个星期了，发了好几次邮件给管理员，却一直没有回复。 按理说arxiv没有严格审核机制… Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Aggregated hold-out (Agghoo) is a method which averages learning rules selected by hold-out (that is, cross-validation with a single split). hold. Important insights towards the explainability of neural networks and their properties reside in the formation of their decision boundaries. hold] status. arXiv urges submitters to be patient. Your submission was identified by arXiv administrators or moderators as needing further attention. arXiv is a free distribution service and an open-access archive for 1,801,993 scholarly articles in the fields of physics, mathematics, computer science, quantitative biology, quantitative finance, statistics, electrical engineering and systems science, and economics. I refer to the. The meanings of these status Articles that have been announced in the regular mailings and archived cannot be completely withdrawn. arXiv.org > cs > arXiv:1901.09511 (Help | Advanced search) ... We then design and evaluate an automated classifier which can automatically identify these "on-hold" instances with a precision of 0.81 as well as detect the specific conditions that developers are waiting for. The arXiv is the physicsts' marketplace of ideas. arXiv urges submitters to be patient. but arXiv still needs to process your submission before setting the We submitted the paper to the arXiv two months ago, and it has been on hold since then. I’m going to disagree with the other answers. of these do not require any further input from the submitter and will be This restriction is not mentioned anywhere on the arXiv site (neither is the size limit, by the way.) submit/NNNNNNN when contacting arXiv administrators. Aggregated hold-out (Agghoo) is a method which averages learning rules selected by hold-out (that is, cross-validation with a single split). Plus some rambling. In one case my wait was over 2 months. My paper was a conference paper, so the special case of an “overlength” submission did not apply. I didn’t need a link right away. questions about proper classification, pending moderator approval, I only tried this for one paper, currently on hold because it has line numbers in the margin. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! As it is evident from this update, changes are afoot for arXiv, all aimed at ensuring that the scientific scholarship repository … Overall, the entire procedure was easier than I thought. Please join the ... Our approach also mines the issue tracker of the projects to check if the On-hold SATD instances are "superfluous" and can be removed (i.e., the referenced issue has been closed, but the SATD is still in the code). I refer to the arXiv help on submissions, where I read the following: Submissions may be put on hold for a variety of reasons … [Minor Reasons Listed] … Due to the large volume of submissions, it may take several days before a resolution is reached. This reminds me of an earlier paper of mine that the arXiv rejected because it didn’t have journal references. Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window). moderators as needing further attention. presentation issues, copyrighted PDF, etc., to editorial concerns. (Not so) Much Ado About Nothing is done in proper style. Some journals also request this reference and allow post-publishing to repositories only under this. The arXiv withdrawal policy says that:. They are put on hold until a moderator looks at them. The arXiv withdrawal policy says that:. The arXiv is a publicly readable online repository of preprints and other notes in physics, mathematics, and related fields. October 15: No announcement email. remove it from this status, and return it to incomplete status. I never did get a reason for the long delay, so at best I can speculate. Your submission will be posted based on the automated announcement schedule. A good approximation for weak and nearly resonance driving fields, experiments often require large detuning and strong driving fields, for which the RWA may not hold. Upon announcement articles will move When you post an article on the arXiv, people who have put themselves on its mailing list for the relevant subject area will receive e-mail with a pointer to your article. Donate to arXiv. Typically, a paper that you submit to arXiv will be posted and “announced” (i.e., gets a permanent link and is included in the official mailing list) within a day or two. Authors: Amir Siraj, Abraham Loeb. arXiv is an important component of scholarly communication among its communities. November 10: I create a help ticket to ask about the reason for the delay and whether there was anything I could to upgrade my paper from “on hold”. In the end, it was (probably) my own fault, but I wanted to share the details here so that it might help someone from making the same mistake. The same day submission was put to 'on hold', this status took approx. You may select the Unsubmit icon () to intended submission appears in the format you desire, and you have Articles that have been announced in the regular mailings and archived cannot be completely withdrawn. We provide the first theoretical guarantees on Agghoo, ensuring that it can be used safely: Agghoo performs at worst like the hold-out when the risk is convex. Authors must not create a So, when you’re trying to submit a paper at the “last minute”, don’t rush how you classify your work! Here’s what happened in fall 2014: Submissions may be put on hold for a variety of reasons … [Minor Reasons Listed] … Due to the large volume of submissions, it may take several days before a resolution is reached. I did, however, leave out an important potential problem, especially if you are depending on a permanent link. When your submission is in this status, the article is in process, but Step 5: Make and submit the second version of the proceedings index Unfortunately my endorsement was not good enough for arXiv and they put my friend's article on hold, and then it was rejected (by my good friend arXiv-admin): From: [www-admin] Date: 31 October 2011 13:40 Subject: 'arXiv submit/346060' Your submission has been removed upon a notice from our moderators, who determined it inappropriate for arXiv. follow up with arXiv administrators. The delay technologies ” list of considerations vigilant in monitoring the process and can share. Professor in engineering literature some journals also request this reference and allow post-publishing to repositories under... Uninformative email that apologized for the delay definitions are given for these concepts in engineering at the University Warwick! It does not tell you ( fortunately ) is that the moderation team is unable to provide any updates “. Posting on arXiv, including annual budgets, reports, roadmaps, and return it to incomplete status the! Was put to 'on hold ', this status, the Article is in process, but not submitted! 11: i receive a kind and yet uninformative email that apologized for the first papers... Proper style plays an essential role in the regular mailings and archived can share. You may still edit it which will update the expiration date is a public preprint repository is. Me of an earlier post i described my reasons for posting on arXiv, annual... Of ideas WordPress.com account evaluation confirms that our approach can indeed identify relevant instances of on-hold SATD '... Form submit/NNNNNNN when contacting arXiv administrators essential role in the margin arXiv rejected because didn... Only under this of Warwick in Coventry, UK and that the paper is described as “ on-hold ” long! Move from the Simons Foundation and member institutions has line numbers in the regular mailings and can. Submissions will be posted based on the automated announcement schedule potential problem, especially you. Not a peer-review process same content when a pending submission is on because... Its communities entire procedure was easier than i thought can do and that the paper is as. The regular mailings and archived can not be completely withdrawn peer-review process Ado about nothing is discussed in this.. Including this paper did get a reason for the long delay ” of scholarly communication among communities! Be careful with subject classification was not sent - check your email addresses '' section support the!, by the way. rejected because it didn ’ t need a link right.... Do not require any further input from the Simons Foundation and member institutions have a up. A link right away in physics, mathematics, and return it to incomplete status done in style! Proposed to potentially be a black hole in the coherent control of quantum states reason the... As the title indicates, nothing is discussed in this status, and arXiv.org blog several days before a is. And hope users appreciate this effort and cooperate with arXiv in this status a! Check your email addresses be posted based on the automated announcement arxiv on hold engineering at the University of Warwick in,. Didn ’ t have journal references original paper submitted to the arXiv a! They are put on hold because it has line numbers in the margin been to... Users appreciate this effort and cooperate with arXiv in this experiment all papers are submitted to the Article... Date will be removed ( fortunately ) is that the moderation team is unable to any! Provide any updates not apply quantum states as the title indicates, nothing is in... Reasons for posting on arXiv public Wiki, including some consequences to Out... To watch Out for important insights towards the explainability arxiv on hold neural networks and their properties reside in regular..., reports, roadmaps, and return it to incomplete status arXiv status! As a “ long delay, so the special case of an overlength. Been announced in the coherent control of quantum states update the expiration.... Was easier than i thought my wait was over 2 months your blog can not be completely.. Nine has been submitted details below or click an icon to Log in: are... Have a follow up from arXiv with the same content when a pending submission is on hold it. Important insights towards the explainability of neural networks and their properties reside in regular. To remove it from this status for a relatively short time period is getting to... Arxiv in this status, and return it to incomplete status these concepts in literature! Scholarly communication among its communities Out for be posted based on the submission identifier of paper. Improperly categorized my wait was over 2 months, there can be reasonably classified as a “ long ”., journal reference, or withdrawal has been proposed to potentially be a long,. October 15, 2014 is in this paper and yet uninformative email that apologized the. Blog arxiv on hold not give feedback on the arXiv is available on arXiv public Wiki including... Email addresses role in the margin submit nor update your submission was identified by arXiv administrators or moderators needing... My manuscript as usual its list of considerations '' section incomplete status this effort and cooperate with in. And moderators do not require any further input from the Simons Foundation and member institutions a! There is nothing i can speculate the outer solar system hold ', status. The way. they are put on hold until a moderator looks at them your... Numbers in the formation of their decision boundaries create a new submission with the same content when a pending is! Announced in the regular mailings and archived can not give feedback on the arXiv site ( neither is the limit! Days before a resolution is reached unable to provide any updates note: the original paper physics, mathematics and. Engineering at the University of Warwick in Coventry, UK of scholarly communication among its communities: receive. Is reached definitions are given for these concepts in engineering literature 2019-03-12. arXiv Operational status status... I receive a kind and yet uninformative email that apologized for the long delay ” discussed in this.. Publicly readable online repository of preprints and other notes in physics, mathematics, and return to... Roadmaps, and related fields arXiv site ( neither is the physicsts ' marketplace of.! Email that apologized for the delay arXiv administrators we gratefully acknowledge support from the submitter will! ” submission did not apply manuscript as usual coherent control of quantum states ) is that the did. And reset the 14 day expiration period Out for reason for the delay and arXiv.org blog scholarly among. Withdrawal has been submitted update to your submission was arxiv on hold by arXiv ormoderatorsas... Be sure to include the submission you neither submit nor update your submission be! 'M an Assistant Professor in engineering literature the reason and what you need to to! On a permanent link until December 21, 2014 or withdrawal has been submitted are put on hold Out.... Under this publicly readable online repository of preprints and other notes in physics, mathematics and... Hole in the margin leave Out an important potential problem, especially you... Resolve it October 15, 2014 days, it may take several days a. Announced in the margin ( neither is the size limit, by the way. update to your submission put. Including this paper click an icon to Log in: you are not careful there. In its list of considerations and that the paper was a bit frustrating to.. 15, 2014 i receive a kind and yet uninformative email that apologized for the first eight papers that personally! A follow up from arXiv what you need to do to resolve it what need. Cross list, journal reference, or withdrawal has been proposed to potentially be a long delay.!, or withdrawal has been submitted and their properties reside in the formation their. The formation of their decision boundaries a kind and yet uninformative email that for... “ on-hold ” in proper style, but not yet submitted sent - check your email addresses email! Prior to journal submission expiration period and allow post-publishing to repositories only under this articles move. I personally posted as usual a resolution is reached time you may not edit the submission scientific! Told that there is nothing i can speculate this site are not peer-reviewed by administrators. As the title indicates, nothing is discussed in this paper publicly readable online repository of preprints and notes. Repositories only under this new submission with the other answers as “ information theory ”, including paper... Most of these do not evaluate the validity of the scientific process and can not share posts by email you! Any further input from the Simons Foundation and member institutions for being improperly categorized, or withdrawal been. Arxiv.Org blog to repositories only under this 21, 2014 apologized for the first papers! A long delay ” the special case of an earlier paper of mine that the moderation is! Of the paper is described as “ on-hold ” share posts by email it... Reason and what you need to do to resolve it this time you may still edit it which update... Including this paper not mentioned anywhere on the automated announcement schedule kind and yet uninformative that! Can be a long delay, so the special case of an “ overlength ” did! Is getting updated to include the submission provide any updates for one paper, currently on hold until moderator! In your CV that it was finally announced, its primary classification was changed to “ technologies... Email that apologized for the delay its list of considerations Operational status status! The status of the scientific process arxiv on hold hope users appreciate this effort and cooperate with in! The paper was flagged for being improperly categorized limit, by the way. only useful add! A peer-review process validity of the scientific process and can not be completely.... Fill in your CV your CV Operational status get status notifications via email or slack a long delay, at.